Home  |   Videos  |  Overview  |  Summaries  |  Proofs  |  Political action  |  Forums  |  Contact
Sign up  |   Buy book in US  |   Buy book in UK  |   Visit www.WhyHumanLifeMakesSense.com
PhilipBitar.com - Political action - Apostasy
Political action


Islam has a core defect that needs to be corrected. Historically, the penalty for apostasy is death, and few modern leaders of Islam have renounced this doctrine to embrace our modern values of freedom of inquiry, freedom of discussion, and freedom of religion. Further information about this may be found in the Wikipedia article Apostasy in Islam and Shaykh Muhammad Sarwar, The Complete Idiotís Guide to the Koran (2003, p. 141).

As a result of the death penalty for apostasy, an American born into Islam is like a person born into slavery: they may dream about freedom, but few will have the courage to risk embracing that freedom because to take that step is to place yourself at risk of being ostracized by Musslims and, worse, of being hunted down and murdered by some violence-prone Musslim man who — filled with the fury of Allah's righteous indignation — seeks to wreak Allah's vengeance on the apostate.

Accordingly, a Musslim apostate keeps a low profile. In a Musslim country, they won't utter a word about their apostasy, keeping it a closely guarded secret. Even in the United States, if a Musslim apostate dares to write about defects in Islam, usually they will use a pseudonym and will take great care to keep their identity and their home address private.

A notable example of such a person is ibn Warraq, who, for years, refused to show his face in public. Other notable apostates include Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Nonie Darwish (not her real name). These people live in constant fear of their lives because of their apostasy. When any of these people speaks publicly, elaborate security arrangements are taken to protect them due to the death threats against them from angry Musslims.

Freedom from retribution for apostasy.  To address this threat to personal freedom, I drafted a constitutional amendment in order to establish a crucial right that I envision will henceforth become foundational to civilization: freedom from retribution for apostasy.

The amendment is presented in the abridged version of my book, and it appears in section 6.3 on culture, under the topic of Islam. I explain how the amendment can be used to foster the maturation of Islam by enlightened Musslims. Such Musslims seek to bring their religion out of the dark ages of its traditional medieval mentality.

This sorry mentality is one that Christianity itself succumbed to starting at the Council of Nicaea under the Roman emperor Constantine, in 325, when Christians who refused to burn their Arian books were placed under the sentence of death. This took place in spite of the fact that, unlike Islam, the origin of Christianity was not in warfare and violent coercion, but in compassion and sacrificial love.

It is sobering to realize that the era of religious freedom is a mere 200 years old, having been established in 1791, with the ratification of amendment 1 of the United States constitution. The religion of Islam must be matured to embrace our modern values of freedom and equality. I believe that the proposed amendment will provide enlightened Musslims the leverage they need to bring their religion to this maturity.

Recent links

Pakistani man sentenced to death for insulting Prophet Muhammad, 2017-06-14

Iranian Muslim, Mohsen Amir-Aslani, executed for heresy, 2014-09-29

Sudanese woman sentenced to death for apostasy, 2014-05-16

Saudi blogger Raif Badawi is convicted of insulting Islam, 2014-05-08

"Badawi had originally been charged with apostasy,...which is punishable by death in Saudi Arabia."

Fears of Iranian apostate living in U.S., 2012-09-18

Youcef Nadarkhani, 2012-05-10, see last 3 paragraphs

Youcef Nadarkhani, Wikipedia

11-year-old Pakistani girl, Rimsha Masih, facing execution, 2012-08-30

Rimsha Masih blasphemy case, Wikipedia

Reference citation.  Philip Bitar, complement to Why? In Pursuit of the Ultimate Answer, Political action / Apostasy, posted at www.philipbitar.com, 2008-12-13.